When one person moves toward and the other moves away, how do we stop getting further and further from each other?
Oh look. We're having THIS fight again.
You know the one. You've had it a hundred times. You can probably predict what your partner is going to say before they say it. You know how you'll respond. And you know how shitty you'll both feel afterward.
Maybe one of you desperately wants to talk things through. You want reassurance. You want to feel connected again.
The other person needs some space. You want them to listen to your stop. You want your partner to stop expecting that you will solve their panic.
The more one person reaches, the further the other pulls away. And the further they pull away, the more desperate the first person becomes.
Pretty soon, nobody is getting what they need.
And the particularly frustrating part? You might both understand exactly what's happening.
You've read the books. You've listened to the podcasts. You've talked about your attachment styles and made agreements about how you want to handle conflict. You have values around boundaries and consent. You want to do it so differently than you watched it go down with your parents.
And yet, here you are again.
Knowing better doesn't always mean being able to do better
One of the relationship patterns I encounter frequently in my practice is the anxious/avoidant dynamic.
These aren't fixed personality types. They're ways we sometimes respond when we feel threatened or overwhelmed. We can flip flop from relationship to relationship – often someone is anxious in one relationship and avoidant in their next. Sometimes they have roots in our childhoods.
For someone in the more anxious role, distress can create an almost irresistible urge to move toward their partner. They want to talk. They need reassurance. They want to resolve things RIGHT NOW.
For someone in the more avoidant role, that same interaction can create an equally powerful urge to get away. They want pause. They want a moment. They feel flooded. They want to stop and to get away RIGHT NOW.
And here's the shitty part. Each person's attempt to take care of themselves can make things worse for the other.
The person pursuing feels abandoned. The person withdrawing feels trapped.
Round and round we go.
I often tell couples caught in this pattern that it's a particularly challenging relationship dynamic. It can take a shitload of work to change. It can also be tremendously rewarding. You're in a relationship with someone who is seeing terrain way different than yours. They have a perspective that is different. They also can create an impetus for you to have to learn to be and do different.
But understanding what's happening isn't necessarily enough to interrupt it.
That's where somatic practice comes in.
For the person who moves toward: can you stay with yourself?
When someone in the more anxious role gets activated, a whole lot can happen in their body.
Maybe their stomach starts churning. Their skin feels tight. There's heat or buzzing. Maybe they're shaking.
And there's this overwhelming urge to move toward their partner. To get reassurance. To make the discomfort stop.
Sometimes the sensations are so intense that getting reassurance feels like the only option.
Which makes it really hard to respect a partner's request for space, even when you genuinely believe in boundaries and consent.
So what if we started somewhere else?
Instead of focusing on how to stop pursuing, we might get curious about what's happening in your body when your partner pulls away.
Can you notice the heat? The buzzing? How fast is your stomach churning? How tight is your skin? Can you sit with the tightness for 30 seconds? Can you notice the speed of your stomach churning and mimic it with the movement of your entire body? Can you match the buzzing inside of you with a sound you make outside?
Can you stay with those sensations for a moment without needing to do something about them?
Can you practice turning them up and down and sitting inside of them?
Can you sit with yourself?
And here's a tricky one: can you experience those sensations without writing a whole story about what they mean?
My stomach is churning. My chest is heavy. The skin on my face feels so incredibly tight.
That's different from:
They're leaving me. They don't love me. This relationship is over. I have to fix this RIGHT NOW.
The sensations are real. The story might be true. It might not. Often times our stories are old.
As we build our capacity to be with uncomfortable sensations, something starts to shift. There's a little more room between what we're experiencing and what we do next.
You might still want reassurance. You might still be scared.
But maybe you can let your partner have the space they've asked for. Maybe you can find some ground and take care of yourself. Maybe you have more choices now than one solution that you have to scream
You don't have to follow every impulse your nervous system throws at you.
And that's a pretty big deal.
For the person who moves away: can you find your way back into yourself? Can you find a way back to the relationship?
For the person in the more avoidant role, the work often looks quite different.
When someone feels overwhelmed by their partner's distress, their world can get very small.
I need to get the fuck away from this person. The most important thing is to get as far away as possible.
That's it. That's all there's room for.
There's no space to remember that you love this person. No room to consider what they're going through. Just the urgent need to get away from someone who feels like they're not listening or respecting your boundaries. Self preservation at all costs.
And sometimes taking space is exactly what's needed.
But what happens when we start working with the body?
Can you find your outside edges? The sides of your rib cage? The outsides of your knees? Your ears?
Feel your feet on the ground? What if you lift and press your toes in succession? What if you swipe your foot back and forth on the ground?
What happens if you breathe into your sides? Can you make your arms move outward with each breath? Can you experience a little more width?
Can you inhabit more of yourself? Can you find a way into your own body?
Sometimes, as we find more breadth in our bodies, we find more breadth in what we're able to experience.
You might still be angry. You might still need space.
But now you can also remember that the person across from you is someone you love. They're having a hard time too.
You can hold your boundary and care about their distress. You might have a little capacity to go back and hear what their saying especially if their panic is not red hot.
When you aren't expected to solve their gigantic feelings, more becomes possible. And you don't have to abandon yourself to stay connected.
Maybe you can begin to imagine coming back toward this relationship you treasure.
The withdrawal can become an ellipsis instead of a period. A pause instead of an end.
We practice where there's enough room to practice
This work we practice doesn't always start live in the middle of a fight.
Sometimes people have enough capacity to slow things down while they're happening. We can notice what's going on in their bodies and experiment with doing something different.
Other times, the activation is just too much.
Asking someone who's completely overwhelmed to pay closer attention to their sensations might not be the place we start.
So we start somewhere easier.
Maybe we practice finding your feet when nothing particularly stressful is happening. Or noticing the edges of your body when you're feeling relatively grounded.
Over time, those skills can become available in harder moments.
There's no prize for practicing at the highest possible level of difficulty. We're trying to build capacity, not prove how much discomfort you can tolerate.
And we're certainly not trying to shame anyone into behaving differently.
Because here's something I see all the time: people already know what they want to do.
They want to respect their partner's boundaries. They want to stay connected. They want to stop repeating patterns that hurt the people they love.
But knowing what you want to do and being able to do it when you're activated are two very different things.
Getting unstuck, together
When both people start developing these capacities, the dynamic can begin to change.
If the person who tends to pursue can find their own ground, the person who withdraws may have more room to come back.
And when the person who tends to withdraw can communicate their need for space without making it feel like the end of the relationship, that can make the separation easier for the person who pursues.
It's not always easy. Practicing being uncomfortable is a hard sell.
And not everyone wants to do that work. That makes sense, especially in a world that is often throwing devastation at us.
But if you do want to try, there's a lot we can practice. And fundamentally developing the capacity to be uncomfortable can add another level in your life and relationships. More choice. More options.
As one client described their experience of our relationship work:
“I understand what is happening, I feel it and I can communicate from new places inside of myself, instead of responding directly from my pain, or my darker, more default places.”
That's what interests me about somatic relationship coaching.
You might already know why you keep having the same fight.
What if you could actually do something different the next time it happens?
I offer online somatic relationship coaching for couples and other relationship constellations. If you're interested in exploring the patterns that keep you stuck, you can learn more about working together.